19 May

Key Features:

  • Installation Speed and Cost: Drywall is favored for its quick installation and cost-effectiveness. Its ease of installation makes it suitable for fast-paced projects, and it is generally more affordable than plaster in terms of both materials and labor.
  • Durability and Soundproofing: Plaster walls are known for their durability and superior soundproofing capabilities. Plaster can outlast drywall and offers better insulation against noise, making it ideal for environments where sound control is important.
  • Aesthetic Appeal and Texture: Plaster provides a unique aesthetic with its ability to create textured finishes and intricate designs. This material is often chosen for its classic look and the character it can add to a space, offering a level of customization that drywall cannot match. 

Drywall vs. Plaster

Welcome to another edition of Lightmen Daily, where we dive deep into the world of construction and design. Today's topic is one that often puzzles homeowners during renovations or new constructions: the choice between drywall and plaster for wall materials. As a team passionate about bringing walls to life, we at Lightmen Painting have a thing or two to share about these popular choices. Whether you're remodeling an old charm or building a modern haven, understanding these materials is key. So, let's roll up our sleeves and delve into the world of drywall and plaster.

"I can be quick and modern or slow and classic. I hold your home together, inside and out. What am I?"

Answer below

Understanding the Basics

Drywall – The Modern Maverick

Drywall, also known as gypsum board, is a modern marvel in home construction. Its popularity stems from its efficiency and practicality. Quick to install, drywall allows for fast construction timelines, making it a favorite in the contemporary home-building industry. It's also easy to repair, which adds to its appeal for both homeowners and builders. I remember the first time I worked with drywall – it felt like stepping into the future of construction. Its efficient and effective nature revolutionized how we approached building and renovating homes.

Plaster – The Traditional Artist

In contrast, plaster represents the grand old art of wall finishes. With a history that spans centuries, plaster is known for its durability and textured charm. Unlike drywall, plastering is a true craft that requires skill and patience. Each layer must be meticulously applied and smoothed to achieve the desired finish. The results, however, are often stunning – offering a unique texture and depth that drywall cannot replicate. Plastering might take longer and demand more expertise, but for those who appreciate the art and tradition of construction, it's a labor of love that pays off in a timeless, elegant finish. 

The Pros and Cons

Weighing Drywall's Advantages and Disadvantages

Advantages of Drywall:

  • Quick Installation: One of drywall's biggest advantages is its quick installation time. It is light and easy to transport, making it ideal for fast-paced construction projects.
  • Easy to Finish: Drywall can be painted or finished within days of installation, allowing for quick turnarounds on projects.
  • Cost-Effective: Drywall is generally more affordable than plaster, both in terms of material costs and labor.

Disadvantages of Drywall:

  • Durability Issues: Drywall is not as durable as plaster and can be easily damaged by moisture or impact. It’s prone to dents, scratches, and holes.
  • Moisture Sensitivity: In humid or wet environments, drywall can become compromised, leading to mold growth or structural issues.
  • Aesthetic Limitations: While drywall is versatile, it lacks the unique textured finish that plaster can provide.

Plaster's Strengths and Weaknesses

Strengths of Plaster:

  • Robust and Durable: Plaster is known for its robustness and durability, often outlasting drywall in terms of lifespan.
  • Better Soundproofing: Plaster walls provide better sound insulation compared to drywall, making them ideal for noise-sensitive areas.
  • Unique Aesthetic: Plaster offers a unique aesthetic with its textured finish and can be molded into various decorative patterns.

Weaknesses of Plaster:

  • Labor-Intensive: Plaster installation is labor-intensive and requires skilled artisans. This makes the installation process longer and more complicated.
  • Costlier: Due to the intensive labor and skill required, plaster can be more expensive than drywall.
  • Challenging Repairs: Repairing plaster can be more challenging and costly compared to drywall, which can be patched relatively easily.

By understanding these pros and cons, homeowners and builders can make informed decisions about which material best suits their needs and preferences. Whether you prioritize quick installation and cost-effectiveness or durability and aesthetic appeal, both drywall and plaster have their distinct benefits and drawbacks. 

In Our Experience:

"We’ve worked extensively with both materials, each offering distinct benefits. Drywall is a modern marvel, ideal for quick installations and budget-friendly projects, perfect for achieving a sleek, contemporary look. On the other hand, plaster is a timeless classic, providing durability and a unique, textured finish that adds character to any space. Our team excels at both transforming drywall into stunning canvases and restoring the historical charm of plaster walls. Whether you seek the quick convenience of drywall or the enduring elegance of plaster, our expertise ensures that your walls will look exceptional and reflect your personal style."

Making the Right Choice for Your Home

Considerations for Drywall

Advantages for Time and Budget Constraints:

  • Quick and Budget-Friendly: If you're building or remodeling with time and budget constraints, drywall is an excellent option. Its quick installation process and cost-effectiveness make it a preferred choice for many homeowners and builders.
  • DIY-Friendly: Drywall is also a great choice for DIY enthusiasts. Its lightweight nature and straightforward installation process allow homeowners to tackle installation projects themselves, potentially saving on labor costs.
  • Moisture-Resistant Options: In areas prone to moisture, such as bathrooms or basements, consider using moisture-resistant drywall (often referred to as green board or blue board). This type of drywall is designed to withstand humid environments better than standard drywall, reducing the risk of mold growth and water damage.

When to Opt for Plaster

Textured Walls with History and Personality:

  • Aesthetic Appeal: Plaster is ideal for those who appreciate textured walls with a bit of history and personality. The unique finishes and decorative options available with plaster can add character and elegance to any space.
  • Soundproofing Benefits: Plaster's density provides better soundproofing compared to drywall, making it a great choice for rooms where noise reduction is important, such as studios, home theaters, or bedrooms.
  • Maintaining Historical Integrity: In historical homes, maintaining the original plaster can preserve the authenticity and value of the property. Plaster restoration can be a meticulous process, but it ensures that the historical charm and architectural integrity of the home are maintained.

Walls That Talk: Drywall vs. Plaster in Home Construction

"I told my friend I prefer plaster walls. He said, 'Oh, for that vintage WiFi-blocking feature?'"

The Lightmen Painting Touch

Our Experience with Both Materials

At Lightmen Painting, we have extensive experience working with both drywall and plaster, allowing us to deliver exceptional results tailored to each material's unique properties.

  • Transforming Drywall: We’ve turned plain drywall into stunning canvases, utilizing techniques that enhance its appearance and durability. From smooth, flawless finishes to creative textures and paint designs, our expertise ensures that your drywall looks anything but ordinary.
  • Restoring Plaster Walls: We take pride in restoring plaster walls to their former glory. Our skilled artisans understand the intricacies of plaster work, from repairing cracks and imperfections to recreating historical textures and patterns. Our restoration projects preserve the charm and character of your home while enhancing its structural integrity.

Custom Solutions for Your Walls

At Lightmen Painting, our approach is to understand the unique needs of each home and homeowner. We believe that your walls should reflect your style and preferences, whether that means a sleek, modern look or a timeless, classic appeal.

  • Modern Look with Drywall: If you’re looking for a contemporary feel, we create clean, smooth drywall finishes that provide a perfect backdrop for any decor. Our expertise in drywall installation and finishing ensures that your walls are both aesthetically pleasing and durable.
  • Classic Beauty of Plaster: For those who love the elegance of plaster, we offer custom plaster solutions that highlight its textured beauty. Whether you want to restore existing plaster walls or add new plaster features, our skilled team delivers exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail.

Maintenance and Upkeep

Keeping Your Drywall in Top Shape

Drywall is relatively low-maintenance but requires some care to keep it looking its best.

  • Avoiding Moisture: Moisture is drywall's biggest enemy. Ensure that areas prone to dampness, like bathrooms and basements, are well-ventilated and use moisture-resistant drywall where necessary. Promptly address any leaks or water damage to prevent mold growth and structural issues.
  • Quick Patch-Ups: For small dings, dents, or holes, quick patch-ups can maintain your drywall’s pristine appearance. Use a patch kit for minor repairs, and follow up with a touch of matching paint to blend seamlessly with the surrounding wall.
  • Regular Cleaning: Dust and dirt can accumulate on drywall surfaces. Regularly clean your walls with a soft cloth or sponge and mild detergent to keep them looking fresh.

Preserving Your Plaster Walls

Plaster walls require a bit more attention to maintain their durability and aesthetic appeal, but the effort is well worth it.

  • Routine Inspections: Regularly inspect plaster walls for any signs of cracks, chips, or damage. Early detection allows for timely repairs, preventing more extensive issues down the line.
  • Professional Repairs: Plaster repairs often require professional expertise. If you notice significant damage or structural concerns, contact a skilled plaster artisan to ensure proper restoration.
  • Cleaning: Clean plaster walls with care to avoid damaging the surface. Use a soft, damp cloth and mild cleaning solution to remove dust and stains. Avoid abrasive cleaners or scrubbing, which can damage the plaster finish.
  • Moisture Control: Similar to drywall, controlling moisture is crucial for plaster walls. Ensure proper ventilation in humid areas and promptly address any leaks to prevent water damage and mold growth.

Plaster demands a bit more attention. Regular checks for cracks and moisture can prolong its life. And remember, repairing plaster is not just fixing a wall; it’s preserving a piece of art.

Choosing between drywall and plaster boils down to your personal needs, the style of your home, and your budget. Whether you opt for the sleek efficiency of drywall or the classic elegance of plaster, Lightmen Painting is here to add the final touches that make your walls speak volumes. So, whatever you choose, make sure it reflects your style, and of course, if you need a splash of color, you know who to call!


People Also Ask:

What are the main differences between drywall and plaster?

Drywall and plaster serve similar purposes but differ in several key ways. Drywall is a modern building material known for its quick installation, cost-effectiveness, and ease of repair. It's made from gypsum board and is commonly used in contemporary construction. Plaster, on the other hand, is a traditional wall finish that offers a durable and textured surface. It requires more skill and time to apply, resulting in a unique, high-quality finish that is better at soundproofing and more resistant to damage over time.

Which material is better for soundproofing: drywall or plaster?

Plaster provides better soundproofing compared to drywall. Due to its density and the multiple layers involved in its application, plaster walls can significantly reduce noise transmission between rooms. This makes plaster an excellent choice for areas where noise reduction is important, such as home theaters, studios, or bedrooms. Drywall, while more affordable and quicker to install, does not offer the same level of sound insulation as plaster.

Is drywall or plaster more cost-effective for home renovations?

For most home renovations, drywall is the more cost-effective option. It is generally cheaper to purchase and install than plaster. The installation process for drywall is quicker, which reduces labor costs. Additionally, drywall repairs are simpler and less expensive compared to plaster. However, if you seek a high-end, durable finish with superior soundproofing and aesthetic appeal, investing in plaster might be worthwhile despite the higher initial cost.


SUBSCRIBE TO OUR BLOG: Stay informed with the latest in Painting and DIY projects by subscribing to Lightmen Painting. Get insights, tips, and more delivered straight to your inbox. We would also love to know what you would like to read about, leave thoughts on where we should go next. Interests, Topics, Ideas, all are welcome.

LP logo

If your in the Portland, Or. area and need advice or a free no obligation estimate call us at 503-389-5758 or email scheduling@lightmenpainting.com

Local Shout Out: 

Celebrating Tualatin Country Club Golf Course: A Tradition of Excellence and Leisure

From the team at Lightmen Painting, we extend our warmest regards to the Tualatin Country Club Golf Course, a prestigious venue that blends sport, community, and tradition. Just as we strive for precision and excellence in our painting projects, Tualatin Country Club provides an impeccable golfing experience, maintaining high standards of course quality and hospitality. The course not only offers a challenging and enjoyable game for golfers but also serves as a social hub, fostering connections within the community, reflecting our commitment to enhancing spaces that bring people together. 

Thanks for stopping by Lightmen Daily! Stay tuned for more practical tips and expert advice on making your painting projects flawless, from wall to floor!


  • Drywall: Also known as gypsum board, a modern building material used for constructing walls and ceilings quickly and efficiently.
  • Plaster: A traditional building material used for wall finishes, known for its durability, textured charm, and historical aesthetic.
  • Visual Transformation: The dramatic change in appearance achieved through wall treatments like painting or plastering, making spaces look new and modern or maintaining a classic, elegant look.
  • Aesthetic Appeal: The visual attractiveness of a material, such as the unique texture and depth that plaster provides compared to the smooth, clean look of drywall.
  • Moisture and Grease Protection: The ability of a wall material to resist damage from moisture and grease, extending the lifespan of the wall.
  • Soundproofing: The ability of a material to block or reduce noise transmission, with plaster generally providing better sound insulation than drywall
  • .Durability: The strength and longevity of a material, with plaster being more robust and lasting longer than drywall.
  • Installation Time: The amount of time required to install a material, with drywall being quicker to install than plaster.
  • Cost-Effective: A measure of the financial efficiency of a material, considering both initial costs and long-term maintenance expenses, with drywall generally being more affordable than plaster.
  • Labor-Intensive: The amount of labor required to install or repair a material, with plaster being more labor-intensive than drywall due to the skill and time needed.
  • Textured Finish: A wall finish that has a distinctive texture, often achieved with plaster, adding character and depth to a room.
  • Maintenance: The ongoing care required to keep a material in good condition, with plaster needing more attention than drywall.
  • DIY-Friendly: Materials and projects that are easy for do-it-yourself enthusiasts to handle, with drywall being more DIY-friendly than plaster.
  • Custom Solutions: Tailored approaches to wall treatments that meet the specific needs and preferences of homeowners, provided by professional painting and plastering services.
  • Moisture-Resistant Drywall: A type of drywall designed to withstand humid environments, reducing the risk of mold growth and water damage.
  • Historical Integrity: The preservation of the original materials and aesthetics in historical homes, often involving the use of plaster to maintain the property's authenticity.
  • Patch-Ups: Minor repairs made to fix small damages in wall materials, with drywall being easier to patch up than plaster.
  • Professional Repairs: Expert services required to fix significant damage in wall materials, often necessary for plaster walls.
  • Cleaning: The regular removal of dust and dirt from wall surfaces to keep them looking fresh, with different techniques required for drywall and plaster.
  • Moisture Control: The practice of managing humidity levels and preventing water damage to maintain the integrity of wall materials. 

Lightmen Painting Serving: Portland, TigardLake Oswego, TualatinWest LinnMilwaukieSherwoodHappy ValleyOregon City, BeavertonHillsboro, Gresham

* The email will not be published on the website.
Paint Project Estimated ROI Calculator

Paint Project Estimated ROI Calculator