17 Apr

Key Considerations:

  • Performance and Longevity: Sherwin-Williams often has the edge in environments requiring high durability and superior finish, while Home Depot’s options like Behr Marquee offer excellent coverage and longevity suitable for most residential projects.
  • Ease of Application: Both brands are praised for their ease of use, but specific product lines like Behr Premium Plus and Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint are noted for their exceptional application properties.
  • Environmental Impact: Both companies have made strides in offering environmentally friendly options, catering to a market that values sustainable and health-conscious products.

Home Depot Paint vs. Sherwin Williams


When it comes to choosing paint, the decision often comes down to comparing top brands like Home Depot's Behr and Glidden versus Sherwin-Williams. Each brand offers unique benefits and has developed a strong market presence through consistent performance and innovation. This overview will delve into each brand's product offerings, quality, and special features to help you make an informed decision.

Product Range and Quality

Both Home Depot and Sherwin-Williams offer a comprehensive range of paint products designed to meet various consumer needs, from basic interior projects to high-end exterior applications.

Home Depot's Paint Selection

Home Depot is well-known for its extensive paint selection, primarily featuring Behr and Glidden. These brands are favored for both DIY projects and professional applications:

  • Behr Premium Plus: Known for its excellent coverage and durability, Behr Premium Plus is a zero-VOC formula that offers a wide range of colors and finishes.
  • Behr Marquee: A higher-end line, Marquee guarantees one-coat coverage and is recognized for its exceptional hide and depth of color.
  • Glidden Premium: Often praised for its affordability combined with reliable performance, Glidden Premium offers good coverage and is durable enough for both interior and exterior use.

These options cater to various customer needs, providing choices for those prioritizing eco-friendliness, coverage, or budget.

Sherwin Williams' Paint Selection

Sherwin-Williams is highly regarded in both the consumer and professional markets, with products that often lead in technology and performance:

  • Emerald: This top-of-the-line paint is renowned for its durability and excellent coverage, featuring resistance to staining and mildew, making it ideal for high-traffic areas and challenging environments.
  • Duration: Known for its longevity, Duration is a favorite for exterior jobs due to its thick, protective coating that stands up well against weathering.
  • SuperPaint: A versatile option, SuperPaint is popular for both interiors and exteriors, providing good coverage, durability, and a wide range of finishes.

Sherwin-Williams paints are typically seen as premium options, offering specialized products that cater to specific needs such as enhanced durability and superior environmental resistance. 

sherwin williams lake oswego

Price Comparison

When comparing the pricing strategies of Home Depot’s paint brands (Behr and Glidden) and Sherwin-Williams, it's evident that each offers distinct value propositions aimed at different segments of the market.

  • Home Depot: Typically, Home Depot's pricing is seen as more budget-friendly, with Behr and Glidden offering competitive rates that attract DIY enthusiasts and homeowners looking for quality at an accessible price point.
  • Sherwin-Williams: Generally, Sherwin-Williams is positioned at a higher price bracket, reflecting its popularity with professional painters and those undertaking high-stakes projects where long-term durability and fewer repaint cycles are valued.

The decision between the two often comes down to balancing the initial cost against the expected performance and longevity of the finish.

In A Nutshell:

Home Depot Paint (Behr and Glidden)

  • Product Range: Offers a broad selection suitable for DIY enthusiasts and professionals. Behr is renowned for its durability and excellent coverage, while Glidden provides reliable performance at a more affordable price.
  • Price: Generally more budget-friendly, appealing to homeowners and DIYers who seek quality without a high expense.
  • Color Options and Customization: Advanced color matching technology and a wide array of colors available.
  • Accessibility: Extensive network of store locations and robust online shopping options.
  • Eco-Friendly Options: Offers low-VOC and zero-VOC options across its product lines, supporting healthier indoor environments and sustainability.
  • Consumer Preference: Particularly favored by DIY consumers for its combination of quality, affordability, and user-friendly products.


  • Product Quality: Known for premium formulations, Sherwin-Williams is favored in professional circles for paints that offer exceptional durability and coverage, such as Emerald and Duration.
  • Price: Positioned at a higher price bracket, reflecting its professional-grade quality and performance.
  • Color Technology: Features advanced tools like ColorSnap® for precise color matching and customization.
  • Professional Services: Offers specialized customer service and expert advice, making it ideal for professional painters and complex projects.
  • Environmental Commitment: Provides a range of eco-friendly paints, emphasizing sustainability without compromising on performance.
  • Professional Preference: Highly regarded by professionals for its consistent quality and superior performance, especially in demanding environments.

Color Options and Customization

Both Home Depot and Sherwin-Williams excel in providing extensive color options and customization services, but they approach customer engagement and technology differently.

  • Home Depot: Utilizes advanced color matching technologies and offers a wide array of online tools to help customers visualize different colors in their spaces before making a purchase. Behr and Glidden paints are available in a vast spectrum of colors, influenced by the latest home decor trends.
  • Sherwin-Williams: Renowned for its ColorSnap® technology, Sherwin-Williams offers sophisticated tools for precise color matching and prediction. Their in-store services provide personalized consultations, making them a favorite among professionals who require exact specifications for large-scale projects.

Ease of Application

Ease of application is crucial for both DIYers and professionals as it impacts the overall time and effort involved in a painting project.

  • User Reviews: Both brands receive positive feedback regarding their ease of application. Behr paints are often noted for their excellent coverage with fewer coats, while Glidden is praised for its quick drying times and ease of use.
  • Professional Feedback: Sherwin-Williams is frequently highlighted in professional circles for its superior formulations that allow for smoother application and a durable finish, which can reduce the need for future touch-ups and maintenance.

Considering these aspects, customers are advised to assess their specific needs for application ease, drying times, and the environment in which the paint will be used, to choose the most suitable option between Home Depot’s and Sherwin-Williams' offerings. 

Availability and Accessibility

Both Home Depot and Sherwin-Williams excel in making their products widely accessible, though their approaches differ slightly due to their business models.

  • Home Depot: With thousands of store locations across the United States, Home Depot offers easy accessibility to a wide range of paint products, including Behr and Glidden. Additionally, their robust online platform allows customers to purchase paints online with options for in-store pickup or home delivery. Home Depot's extensive DIY resources and workshops also support homeowners undertaking their own painting projects.
  • Sherwin-Williams: While Sherwin-Williams has fewer retail locations compared to Home Depot, it is heavily focused on serving both the consumer market and professional contractors. Sherwin-Williams stores often provide a more specialized customer service experience, with staff trained to offer detailed advice and support for both simple home projects and complex commercial endeavors.

Performance and Longevity

When it comes to performance and longevity, both Home Depot and Sherwin-Williams have their strengths, which are reflected in customer and professional feedback.

  • Home Depot: Behr and Glidden paints are often praised for their excellent coverage and durability within their price range. Behr’s Premium Plus and Marquee lines, in particular, are noted for their long-lasting finishes and superior washability.
  • Sherwin-Williams: Known for its high-quality formulations, Sherwin-Williams offers paints like Emerald and Duration, which are highly regarded for their exceptional resistance to fading and weather conditions. These products are frequently chosen for their ability to withstand harsh environments and maintain their aesthetic appeal over time.

Environmental Considerations

Both companies have made significant strides in offering environmentally friendly painting solutions.

  • Home Depot: Offers a wide range of low-VOC and zero-VOC options through its Behr and Glidden lines, catering to consumers who are conscious of environmental and indoor air quality impacts.
  • Sherwin-Williams: Also provides a substantial selection of eco-friendly paints, including zero-VOC formulations across several of its product lines. Sherwin-Williams emphasizes sustainability in their product development, aiming to reduce environmental impact without compromising on quality.

These eco-friendly options reflect a growing industry trend towards sustainability, offering consumers paints that not only perform well but also contribute to healthier living environments and adhere to stricter environmental regulations. Both brands’ efforts in this area ensure that customers have access to safe and sustainable products for their homes and businesses. 

Professional and Consumer Preferences

When considering the preferences of painting professionals and DIY enthusiasts, insights into brand loyalty and satisfaction play a crucial role:

  • Professional Preferences: Many professional painters tend to prefer Sherwin-Williams due to its high-quality output, consistency across batches, and superior customer service aimed at professionals. Products like Sherwin-Williams' Emerald and Duration are especially popular for their excellent coverage and long-lasting durability, which are vital for commercial projects.
  • Consumer Preferences: For DIY consumers, Home Depot's Behr paints often stand out due to their cost-effectiveness and high-quality results. Behr Marquee, for instance, is highly rated in consumer reviews for its one-coat coverage and vibrant color selection, making it a favorite for home renovation projects.


Both Home Depot and Sherwin-Williams offer distinct advantages depending on the needs and scale of painting projects:

  • Home Depot is ideal for DIY projects and consumers looking for high-quality paint at a more accessible price point. The availability of Behr and Glidden paints ensures a wide selection of options to suit various interior and exterior needs.
  • Sherwin-Williams is particularly suited to professional painters and large-scale projects, offering specialized products that cater to demanding conditions and providing a level of durability that professionals trust.

When choosing between Home Depot and Sherwin-Williams, consider factors such as the project's complexity, the need for specialized paints, and budget constraints.


Before making your next paint purchase, thoroughly assess your project requirements and budget constraints. Visit local Home Depot and Sherwin-Williams stores to speak with experienced staff who can provide further guidance based on your specific needs. Taking the time to review product specifications and testing samples can greatly aid in selecting the ideal paint for your project, ensuring both satisfaction and long-term durability.


People Also Ask:

What precautions should be taken when painting interiors while the house is occupied?

When painting your home's interior while still residing in it, prioritize proper ventilation to manage paint fumes effectively. Use fans and keep windows open to ensure air circulation. Choose low or no-VOC paints to reduce odor and chemical exposure, particularly important in homes with children or sensitive individuals. Additionally, plan the project room by room to minimize disruption to daily routines.

How can you prepare your home for painting while living in it?

Start by moving furniture away from the walls and cover it with drop cloths or plastic sheeting to protect from drips. Remove all wall hangings and cover the floor with drop cloths. Secure valuables and delicate items in a safe room or area away from the painting zone. Consider setting up a designated non-paint zone where daily activities can continue unaffected by the ongoing work.

Is it safe to stay at home during an interior painting project?

Yes, it is generally safe to stay at home during an interior painting project if proper precautions are taken. Use paints with low VOC levels to minimize health risks and ensure rooms are well-ventilated. It's also beneficial to use dust barriers and keep the work area tidy to prevent the spread of dust and paint particles throughout the house. If any family members have asthma or other respiratory issues, additional precautions, like staying in a different part of the house or temporarily relocating, may be advisable.


SUBSCRIBE TO OUR BLOG: Stay informed with the latest in Painting and DIY projects by subscribing to Lightmen Painting. Get insights, tips, and more delivered straight to your inbox. We would also love to know what you would like to read about, leave thoughts on where we should go next. Interests, Topics, Ideas, all are welcome.

LP logo

If your in the Portland, Or. area and need advice or a free no obligation estimate call us at 503-389-5758 or email scheduling@lightmenpainting.com

Thanks for stopping by Lightmen Daily! Stay tuned for more practical tips and expert advice on making your painting projects flawless, from wall to floor!

Lightmen Painting Serving: Portland, Tigard, Lake Oswego, Tualatin, West Linn, Milwaukie, Sherwood, Happy Valley, Oregon City, Beaverton, Hillsboro, Gresham

* The email will not be published on the website.
Paint Project Estimated ROI Calculator

Paint Project Estimated ROI Calculator